“Subsidy is gone.” — Bola Ahmed Tinubu, 29 May 2023

By Pledge Tracker Editorial — 23 October 2026

Rating: Compromise

 

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu promised in October 2022 to phase out Nigeria’s petrol subsidy and dedicate the freed resources to infrastructure, agriculture, education, healthcare and social welfare programmes (Tinubu, 2022). The subsidy is gone; what was promised in return has not clearly followed. More than three years into his term, the first half of that promise has been substantially acted on. The second half — the redirection of savings to named sectors — remains only partially evidenced, and in two cases contradicted by the public record (World Bank, 2026).

What the government did

President Tinubu announced the end of the subsidy in his inaugural address on 29 May 2023, declaring “subsidy is gone” and committing to re-channel the funds into public infrastructure, education, healthcare, and jobs (Tinubu, 2023). Pump prices rose sharply within days (BBC News, 2023). The downstream petroleum sector was formally and fully deregulated in September 2024, ending the exchange-rate-differential regime that had quietly sustained price support through NNPCL’s accounts (Punch, 2025).

What the independent record shows

The World Bank’s October 2026 Nigeria Development Update confirms that federation revenues rose by 69 percent in real terms between 2023 and 2025, attributing the gains “largely” to exchange-rate reforms, subsidy removal, and stronger revenue administration (World Bank, 2026). State-level revenues rose 93 percent in real terms over the same period. The share of state expenditure going to capital investment rose from 46 percent to 61 percent, with the largest increases in transport, housing, and agriculture (World Bank, 2026). Three of the five sectors named in the original promise — infrastructure (via transport), agriculture, and social-welfare adjacent spending (via housing) — show measurable gains at the state level. This is partial corroboration of the redirection commitment.

Where the promise falls short

Two of the five named sectors show no corresponding gain. Education’s share of state expenditure fell from 14.9 percent to 12.1 percent over the same period. Healthcare’s share remained flat at approximately 7 percent (World Bank, 2026). Education’s share fell. Healthcare stayed flat. The promise said otherwise.

The timeline of the subsidy phase-out is also more complicated than the inaugural announcement suggested. The World Bank found that subsidy-type payments continued until October 2024 — nearly 17 months after the “subsidy is gone” declaration — accruing ₦7.74 trillion in debt owed by the Federal Government to NNPCL (FIJ, n.d.; Punch, 2025). During this period, NNPCL remittances to the Federation Account fell from ₦1.1 trillion in 2023 to ₦0.6 trillion in 2024, as retained revenue was used to cover these obligations (FIJ, n.d.).

The government’s savings claim

So where did the money go? In August 2026, Finance Minister Taiwo Oyedele stated that ₦15.8 trillion in subsidy savings had been mobilised between June 2023 and December 2025 — ₦5.4 trillion at the federal level and ₦10.4 trillion at the state and local government level (BBC News Pidgin, 2026). No independent reconciliation of that figure exists in open sources, and the breakdown has not been formally presented to the National Assembly as an audited account. Senator Abdul Ningi put the same question to ministers in the chamber: “How much has truly been saved from the removal of the subsidy, and where has the money gone?” (The Guardian, n.d.).

A fresh complication in 2026

In October 2026, the Federal Government introduced a 30-day petrol discount at NNPC Retail stations with a proposed ex-gantry ceiling of ₦1,350 per litre, alongside expanded CNG support and household-level interventions (Premium Times, n.d.). The Finance Minister described these measures as retail-margin adjustments rather than subsidy (Premium Times, n.d.). The World Bank and IMF have previously argued that below-cost petroleum supply constitutes subsidy regardless of its accounting treatment (Punch, 2025). The classification question is unresolved and consequential — if the 2026 scheme is subsidy by economic definition, the trajectory of this promise has partially reversed.

Why we rated this Compromise

The promise contained two commitments: phase out the subsidy, and redirect the savings to five named sectors. The first was substantively acted on but with major carve-outs — the subsidy did not truly end until October 2024, and price-support mechanics reappeared in 2026. The second is partially evidenced for three of the five named sectors and contradicted for two. The government’s headline savings figure of ₦15.8 trillion has not been independently audited or tabled to the legislature. A rating of Kept would overstate what the evidence supports. A rating of Not Done would ignore the real revenue gains and the measurable increases in state-level transport, housing, and agricultural spending. Compromise reflects both.

What we are watching

Whether the 2026 NNPC discount scheme is maintained, expanded, or quietly reclassified. Whether the National Assembly receives and publishes a reconciled account of the ₦15.8 trillion savings claim. Whether the 2027 federal budget contains any line explicitly funded by subsidy savings. Whether education and healthcare expenditure shares recover in subsequent years. The question this rating leaves open is the one Senator Ningi asked — where has the money gone? This rating will be re-reviewed in the first quarter of 2027.

Editorial note on sources

Baseline figures for 2022 subsidy spending vary by source and definition. The ₦4.3 trillion figure cited by BBC News reflects budget provision (BBC News, 2023). A government document reported by FIJ gives ₦2.0 trillion, reflecting NNPC under-recovery (FIJ, n.d.). Both are defensible under their own definitions; we have used the budget-provision figure as the primary baseline. The Senator Ningi quotation is sourced to a newspaper report whose publication date we could not independently confirm (The Guardian, n.d.); if verification fails before publication, the quote will be replaced with an attributed paraphrase. Reference titles drawn from URL slugs (FIJ; Premium Times) and approximate dates (Punch, February 2025) will be confirmed against the live pages before publication. A fuller reconciliation is in our methodology notes.

References

BBC News. (2023, May 29). [Bola Tinubu announces end of fuel subsidy in inaugural address]. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-65737846

BBC News Pidgin. (2026, August 19). How Nigeria govment spend di money dem see from fuel subsidy removal. https://www.bbc.com/pidgin/articles/cy9w38nv74jo

Foundation for Investigative Journalism. (n.d.). Report: NNPCL remits half proceeds, still clearing old debts in 2025. https://fij.ng/article/report-nnpcl-remits-half-proceeds-still-clearing-old-debts-in-2025/

Premium Times. (n.d.). NNPC petrol discount is not fuel subsidy – Finance Minister. https://www.premiumtimesng.com/business/business-news/915610-nnpc-petrol-discount-is-not-fuel-subsidy-finance-minister.html

Punch. (2025, February). FG, NNPCL work out N7.7tn fuel subsidy debt payment. https://punchng.com/fg-nnpcl-work-out-n7-7tn-fuel-subsidy-debt-payment/

The Guardian. (n.d.). Senate erupts as Edun seeks executive session on fuel subsidy proceeds. https://guardian.ng/news/senate-erupts-as-edun-seeks-executive-session-on-fuel-subsidy-proceeds/

Tinubu, B. A. (2022). Renewed hope: Action plan for a better Nigeria [Party manifesto]. All Progressives Congress.

Tinubu, B. A. (2023, May 29). First inaugural address by President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, delivered on May 29, 2023, at the Eagle Square, Abuja [Speech transcript]. State House Nigeria. https://statehouse.gov.ng/first-inaugural-address-by-president-bola-ahmed-tinubu-delivered-on-may-29-2023-at-the-eagle-square-abuja/

World Bank. (2026, October 8). Nigeria Development Update, October 2026: Beyond the federal purse — how higher revenues shaped state priorities [Press release]. https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2026/10/08/higher-revenues-better-lives-strengthening-state-spending-for-growth-jobs-services

 

No comment yet, add your voice below!


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *